The Lover speaks to the Hearers of his Songs in Coming Days

W. B. Yeatsfirst published 1899from The Wind Among the Reeds8 lines

Earlier titled "Hanrahan speaks to the Lovers of his Songs in coming Days", "A Lover Speaks to the Hearers of His Songs in Coming Days"

O women, kneeling by your altar rails long hence,When songs I wove for my beloved hide the prayer,And smoke from this dead heart drifts through the violet airAnd covers away the smoke of myrrh and frankincense;Bend down and pray for all that sin I wove in song,Till the Attorney for Lost Souls cry her sweet cry,And call to my beloved and me: “No longer flyAmid the hovering, piteous, penitential throng.”

Text: Poetry, by W. B. Yeats (Standard Ebooks, 2024), from the collected editions of 1908 to 1928. Public domain.

In brief

Summary

A dead poet asks future women to pray for his sinful love songs.

The speaker imagines himself long dead. Women of a future time kneel at the altar rails, and his love songs, still in their minds, "hide the prayer"; the smoke of his "dead heart" drifts through the church and covers the incense. He asks them to pray for "all that sin I wove in song", until the Virgin Mary, "the Attorney for Lost Souls", calls to him and his beloved that they need wander no longer among the penitent dead. It is a confession, but also a confident claim that his songs will still be heard.

Lines to remember

O women, kneeling by your altar rails long hence,
Bend down and pray for all that sin I wove in song,

Line by line

  1. Lines 1 to 4In a future church

    He addresses women "kneeling by your altar rails long hence". His songs are so present in their minds that they "hide the prayer", and the smoke from his "dead heart" covers "the smoke of myrrh and frankincense". Love poetry crowds out worship, even after his death.

  2. Lines 5 to 8A prayer for the lovers

    He asks the women to "Bend down and pray" for the sin in his songs. He hopes for the moment when "the Attorney for Lost Souls", the Virgin Mary pleading for sinners, will call to both lovers to "No longer fly" among the "hovering, piteous, penitential throng".

Themes

Love and religion

Earthly love and Christian worship pull against each other. His songs are a "sin" and distract from prayer, yet he trusts prayer to save him. The Virgin Mary is pictured as a lawyer arguing the case of lost souls, a striking image that makes salvation a matter of mercy rather than merit.

Poetry and fame

The poem assumes that his songs will still be heard "long hence", in churches, by women he will never meet. The smoke of his "dead heart" outlasting the incense is a way of saying that the poems will outlive him. The request for prayer is humble, but the confidence behind it is not.

Context

In The Wind Among the Reeds (1899) the poem was "Hanrahan speaks to the Lovers of his Songs in coming Days", spoken by Red Hanrahan, the wandering poet of Yeats's stories, and it began "O, colleens, kneeling by your altar rails long hence". Later versions made the speaker a nameless lover and changed the Irish "colleens" (girls) to "women", loosening the tie to Hanrahan.

Form

Eight long lines of six stresses, in two quatrains rhymed abba cddc ("hence", "prayer", "air", "frankincense"; "song", "cry", "fly", "throng"). The long, rolling lines suit a prayer or a chant, and the enclosing rhymes make each half feel complete.

Retitled and revised: 'Hanrahan speaks to the Lovers of his Songs in coming Days' (1899, Gutenberg 32233) began 'O, colleens, kneeling by your altar rails long hence'; later 'O women, kneeling by your altar rails long hence' (Standard Ebooks).